If you've faced a DUI offense, finding the right insurance provider can be intimidating. Several companies cater specifically to high-risk drivers, each with its own strengths. From Progressive's flexible coverage options to State Farm's robust claims handling, your choices can greatly impact your premium and overall experience. Understanding these differences will help you navigate this challenging landscape and find the best fit for your needs. Let's explore these options further.
Key Takeaways
- Progressive offers coverage for high-risk drivers post-DUI with competitive rates and the option to file an SR-22 for compliance.
- State Farm has significant rate increases post-DUI but offers strong claims handling and bundling discounts for home and auto policies.
- USAA provides competitive rates for military families but may deny DUI-related claims, with higher premiums for drivers with a DUI conviction.
- The General specializes in affordable coverage for high-risk drivers needing SR-22 filings, with flexible payment plans and attentive customer service.
- National General targets high-risk drivers, offering competitive rates for first-time DUI offenders and discounts for safe driving and substance abuse therapy completion.
Progressive

When considering insurance options after a DUI conviction, Progressive stands out for its willingness to provide coverage, albeit at higher rates.
As a high-risk driver, you can expect premiums to rise—averaging $2,271 for full coverage and $987 for minimum coverage. While rates typically increase by about 13% post-DUI, Progressive often remains more competitive compared to other insurers. Additionally, insurance companies may refuse coverage for DUI convictions, making Progressive a valuable option in the marketplace. If required, they can file an SR-22, ensuring compliance with state regulations. In Texas, obtaining an SR-22 is essential for high-risk drivers to reinstate their driving privileges after certain infractions. You may see a decrease in premiums over time, especially if you maintain a clean driving record.
As a high-risk driver, expect rising premiums, with Progressive often offering competitive rates post-DUI.
Progressive accommodates single DUI convictions effectively, making it a viable option when seeking insurance in a challenging market for high-risk drivers.
State Farm
State Farm provides a different approach for drivers with DUI convictions compared to Progressive. While it offers both full and minimum coverage options, be aware that extensive coverage typically excludes damages from DUI incidents.
Expect significant rate increases of 10%-40% following a DUI conviction, with average annual premiums around $1,231. Monthly payments can reach about $102. However, bundling home and auto policies may reduce your overall costs by up to 17%.
Although State Farm's handling of claims scores above industry averages, the required SR-22 filing can further inflate costs. Overall, while State Farm can provide solid customer support and discounts, its policy exclusions and rate hikes after a DUI warrant careful consideration.
USAA
Although USAA offers competitive rates and superior customer service primarily for military members and their families, it's crucial to understand the implications of DUI offenses on your coverage.
USAA typically excludes damages resulting from DUIs, which can lead to denied claims and potential policy non-renewal. If you face a DUI, you might need to file an SR-22 or FR-44, which can complicate your policy terms.
While full coverage costs around $215 monthly post-DUI, insurers perceive increased risk, often raising rates considerably. Even expunged convictions may still affect your premiums.
The General

If you're seeking insurance after a DUI offense, The General offers specialized coverage tailored for drivers considered high-risk.
They focus on providing affordable options for non-standard drivers, including those needing SR-22 filings. The General's flexible payment plans allow you to manage premiums through monthly installments, easing financial burdens.
Their customer service is particularly attentive to individuals with imperfect driving records, ensuring you receive assistance throughout the process. You can quickly obtain quotes online or via phone, streamlining your application.
While DUI convictions typically lead to higher premiums, The General aims to mitigate these costs with competitive rates. Additionally, maintaining a clean driving record can help normalize your rates over time, providing a pathway to more affordable insurance in the future.
National General
National General stands out in the insurance market by catering specifically to high-risk drivers, including those with a DUI on their record. They offer a range of coverage options, including extensive, collision, and liability, although policies typically exclude DUI-related incidents.
For first-time DUI offenders, National General provides competitive rates, though you can expect premiums to be higher than standard offerings. Discounts for safe driving and completion of substance abuse therapy can help mitigate costs. Their unique valet reimbursement services add convenience during claims.
However, it's important to review individual policy documents to understand specific exclusions and state regulations that may impact your coverage options. Overall, National General serves as a viable choice for high-risk drivers seeking insurance after a DUI.
Direct Auto
Direct Auto Insurance provides a viable option for drivers with DUI convictions, ensuring that they can maintain coverage despite their high-risk status.
They offer various insurance types, including liability, and assist in filing necessary SR-22 and FR-44 forms. Their flexible payment plans cater to different budgets, while discounts are available for good grades and defensive driving courses, helping you manage costs.
Additionally, Direct Auto stands out with non-owner insurance for those without vehicles needing SR-22 coverage. Their customer support is designed to assist you in policy management and compliance with state requirements.
Mercury Insurance

Mercury Insurance stands out as a solid option for drivers with DUI offenses, offering a range of coverage types tailored to meet high-risk needs. You can select from liability, collision, and extensive coverage, ensuring you meet state requirements.
Their uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage aligns with your bodily injury liability limits, providing essential protection. With a national presence, Mercury operates in multiple states, enhancing accessibility.
Their customer service is notable, featuring a convenient portal and a streamlined claims process available 24/7. Additionally, you can benefit from various discounts, such as multi-policy and good driver discounts, to help mitigate costs.
Mercury also offers specialized options like rental car reimbursement and roadside assistance to further support your driving experience.
Conclusion
When maneuvering through insurance after a DUI, choosing the right provider is vital. Progressive, State Farm, and others offer tailored solutions, but it's important to weigh your options carefully. Curiously, drivers with a DUI can see their premiums increase by an average of 80%. This statistic underscores the significance of finding a provider that not only understands your situation but also offers competitive rates and extensive coverage. Making an informed choice can greatly impact your financial future.